13 Privateness-Centered, Various Search Engines to Google

Google options are all over the place, however are they any good?

To reply this query, we researched a number of widespread various serps. Our fundamental judging criterion is how every search engine fared in its dedication to defending consumer information and privateness. 

Listed below are those that bought our approval:

Startpage is successfully Google with out the monitoring. 

In line with the Netherlands-based search engine, your queries are anonymized earlier than search outcomes are pulled from Google. This implies all figuring out data is blanketed, together with your IP handle. No monitoring cookies are used both.

Startpage additionally complies with GDPR, a European Union regulation that protects customers’ information. Nonetheless, it is best to know the nation is a part of the 9 Eyes intelligence alliance, which shares mass surveillance information with eight international locations.

Characteristic highlight

The “Nameless View” characteristic permits you to go to web sites out of your search outcomes anonymously for each desktop and cell. It primarily behaves like a (free) VPN.

DuckDuckGo is definitely probably the most well-known personal search engine round—and the antithesis to Google in the case of favoring consumer privateness. 

Your search historical past is saved in a non-identifiable method. This implies monitoring cookies and private identifiers, resembling IP addresses, will not be saved.

Even though DuckDuckGo’s outcomes are pulled from over 400 sources (together with Microsoft’s Bing), DuckDuckGo assures its customers that it doesn’t share any private data with them. 

The identical applies to DuckAssist—a brand new sort of InstantAnswers in DuckDuckGo’s SERPs—powered by giant language fashions from OpenAI and Anthropic. DuckDuckGo says it doesn’t share any information with the 2 content material companions.

A potential draw back for DuckDuckGo is that it’s primarily based within the U.S., which conducts mass surveillance packages like PRISM. (The U.S. can be a part of the 5 Eyes.)

Characteristic highlight

DuckDuckGo’s “Bangs” characteristic takes you instantly to look outcomes on different websites. For instance, typing “!w” and a key phrase like “singapore” (i.e., “!w singapore”) takes you on to Wikipedia’s web page for Singapore.

Courageous Search is a part of Courageous Software program, which makes Courageous, a privacy-focused browser. Its founders embody Brendan Eich (creator of JavaScript and co-founder of browser Mozilla Firefox) and Brian Bondy (former senior platform engineer at Mozilla). 

Whereas it was once reliant on Google and Bing for its SERPs, it’s now moved on to finish search independence. Each internet result’s now served by its personal index.

For extra privateness, you’ll be able to select to show this toggle off and conduct guide searches, e.g., “issues to do in [location].”

A factor to notice, although: In 2020, Courageous was caught routinely including affiliate hyperlinks to cryptocurrency URLs. I’ll go away it as much as you to resolve whether or not it actually made a mistake and whether or not it’s rehabilitated its popularity.

Characteristic highlight

Like Bing and Google Bard, Courageous has a brand new AI characteristic (“Summariser”) that gives concise and to-the-point solutions.

Swisscows is a Switzerland-based search engine that has its personal index for German-language queries. For all different languages, outcomes are pulled from Bing. However this isn’t a difficulty, given that each one search queries are stripped of non-public identifiers.

The search engine additionally omits the usage of monitoring cookies and geo-targeting.

Swisscows’ distinctive promoting proposition (USP) is family-friendliness: It routinely filters out violent and pornographic search outcomes.

So far as privateness goes, Switzerland is just not a part of an intelligence alliance, nevertheless it does have a Mutual Authorized Help Treaty with the U.S.

Characteristic highlight

Swisscows has music search, which is powered by Soundcloud.

MetaGer is a Germany-based, open-source metasearch engine. Its servers run on renewable power.

Outcomes are pulled from Scopia, Bing, OneNewspage, and OneNewspage (Video), so that they’re fairly well timed. It’s also possible to deselect the major search engines used or create a blacklist of internet sites within the settings.

We like how clear MetaGer is in its dealing with of consumer data, from queries to maps. Nonetheless, it’s not with out caveats: The search engine shops your full IP handle for 96 hours, and your title and electronic mail handle are stored if you happen to fill out its contact type.

Nevertheless, it does use an anonymizing proxy that ensures you keep full management over your information.

Characteristic highlight

The “Do you know” field (to the precise of search outcomes) gives tidbits about MetaGer and easy methods to refine your searches. It’s also possible to click on on the textual content to view the full record of suggestions.

Mojeek is a crawler-based search engine with its personal search index of over 6 billion pages. This makes it wonderful for unbiased data. However it additionally means there could also be restricted outcomes, because it doesn’t pull outcomes from different serps.

It was the primary search engine to have a no-tracking coverage. Your private information will even by no means be offered or distributed, which is a big plus in our books. In the event you’ve stuffed out its contact type, you’ll be able to request to have the knowledge deleted too, as per the GDPR.

All that stated, Mojeek relies within the U.Okay., which is a part of the 5 Eyes intelligence alliance.

Characteristic highlight

The emotion-based search classification characteristic means that you can enter a key phrase and search by emotion.

Qwant is a Paris-based search engine whose search outcomes are powered by Bing and its personal internet crawler. It’s absolutely accessible in over 30 international locations however, alas, not Singapore.

Qwant claims to be personal, and it says it doesn’t observe your geolocation, gather information, or use monitoring cookies. Nevertheless, it retains your IP handle for fraud detection functions. Additionally, since 2016, Qwant began sending information to Microsoft Bing Adverts with out the knowledgeable consent of its customers. It solely disclosed this in mid-2021.

Whereas Qwant gives GDPR safety, France is a part of the 9 Eyes intelligence alliance.

Characteristic highlight

Qwant gives a “maps” characteristic with out monitoring.

Do you know each motion you are taking in your digital machine emits carbon dioxide? And Google performs an enormous half in it: It’s accountable for ~40% of the web’s carbon footprint.

To counteract this, personal search engine Ecosia donates 80% of its earnings to tree-planting tasks, or roughly one tree for each 45 searches made. It has additionally constructed a photo voltaic plant in order that its servers can run on clear energy.

Ecosia isn’t absolutely personal. It collects search information and personally identifiable data, each of that are solely anonymized after seven days. However we reckon utilizing the search engine is a worthy trade-off, because it seeks to deal with local weather change.

Characteristic highlight

Your variety of searches is proven on a scoreboard (until you select to clear your browser cookies), permitting you to maintain observe of your impression on the setting.

Why do serps want to trace you? The easy reply is as a result of that’s how they make cash. 

Search is free, so serps need to earn a living through promoting. To serve higher advertisements and assist advertisers attain clients effectively, serps want information.

However what if it doesn’t need to be that approach? Kagi thinks there’s a unique approach. Slightly than the usual advertisements mannequin, Kagi has determined to go for a subscription mannequin.

Kagi is actually personal—its privateness coverage is in depth and clear. However will folks care sufficient about privateness and Google’s domination that they’ll pay to make use of a search engine? Kagi definitely thinks so. And so do some folks—as of the final replace, it has ~2,600 paid subscribers.

Characteristic highlight

Like most serps as of late, Kagi gives an AI-powered summarizer.

SearX is a free and open-source metasearch engine. Its fundamental goal is privateness, which suggests it doesn’t share customers’ IP addresses, doesn’t use monitoring cookies, and even prevents customers’ question key phrases from showing in server logs.

In the event you click on a search end result, you’re despatched on to the location—quite than a tracked redirect hyperlink like what Google does.

Characteristic highlight

The rationale why SearX is personal is it’s designed for customers to run personal cases on their very own computer systems. Right here’s SearX’s documentation. However if you happen to’re not technically refined however nonetheless need to be protected privacy-wise, you should use publicly accessible cases. Right here’s a listing.

Need to use Google with out all of the monitoring? Strive Whoogle.

Whoogle is much like SearX—it’s a non-public occasion hosted by yourself pc. Besides that this time ’spherical, you’re getting Google’s search outcomes. And also you’re getting them with out advertisements, JavaScript, AMP hyperlinks, cookies, or IP handle monitoring.

The one draw back of utilizing Whoogle is that you simply’ll must be considerably technically proficient. Right here’s the GitHub documentation and easy methods to deploy. 

Contemplating this, it’s clear it’s not for everybody. But when you understand how to program—and are critical about privateness—then it is best to positively think about Whoogle or SearX.

Characteristic highlight

Whoogle has constructed DuckDuckGo’s “Bangs” into its search.

Yep is a privacy-oriented search engine with a 90/10 income share mannequin—90% of promoting income will probably be paid on to creators. It’s created by us, Ahrefs.

If you search on Google, you see SERP options that present on the spot solutions, directions, and different varieties of content material:

The issue is that Google creates no content material itself. These are all taken from webpages and content material creators. In consequence, Google steals clicks from these web sites and generates the income itself through advertisements. 

In truth, in a single well-known case, Google began utilizing CelebrityNetWorth’s content material for its featured snippets. CelebrityNetWorth’s site visitors declined by 65% in a 12 months and Brian Warner, the founder, needed to lay off half his workers.

We need to change that. We don’t desire a search mannequin the place serps generate extra income from content material than the creators themselves. That’s why we created Yep. 

Consider it like YouTube. YouTube’s mannequin of paying creators has generated a complete ecosystem of YouTubers. That’s how we’re getting such high-quality video content material. Satirically, YouTube belongs to Google, however Google isn’t making use of that mannequin to its search engine.

Characteristic highlight

Yep summarizes the highest search outcomes for you.

In the event you consider in the way forward for blockchain-based expertise and are in search of a privacy-oriented search engine, then Presearch might be for you.

Presearch is a decentralized search engine. As a substitute of utilizing a central server to retailer and serve information, search engine work like crawling, indexing, and question processing is distributed amongst nodes. The nodes then get rewarded with Presearch’s token (PRE) for processing the search outcomes.

This act of decentralization, advocates consider, removes Google’s skill to “play God” and censor/limit search outcomes. That is much like Courageous’s mannequin, the place Courageous additionally offers rewards within the type of tokens (BAT). 

Characteristic highlight

If its outcomes don’t fulfill you, Presearch gives shortcuts to different serps.

Ultimate ideas

Whereas Google dominates the worldwide search engine market, it has had its fair proportion of criticism: antitrust points, making a filter bubble, violating consumer privateness, and extra.

For customers, various serps could also be one workaround. However don’t take our phrase for it; check out those on this record to resolve what works greatest for you.

Bought questions or feedback? Ping me on Twitter.